Econometrica: Apr 1977, Volume 45, Issue 3

Manipulation of Schemes that Mix Voting with Chance

https://doi.org/0012-9682(197704)45:3<665:MOSTMV>2.0.CO;2-3
p. 665-681

Allan Gibbard

A decision scheme makes the probabilities of alternatives depend on individual strong orderings of them. It is strategy-proof if it logically precludes anyone's advantageously misrepresenting his preferences. It is unilateral if only one individual can affect the outcome, and duple if it restricts the final outcome to a fixed pair of alternatives. Any strategy-proof decision scheme, it is shown, is a probability mixture of schemes each of which is unilateral or duple. If it guarantees Pareto optimal outcomes, it is a probability mixture of dictatorial schemes. If it guarantees ex ante Pareto optimal lotteries, it is dictatorial.

Log In To View Full Content

Back