p.471

Relative Utilitarianism

Amrita Dhillon
Jean-François Mertens

Abstract

‘If empirically meaningful interpersonal comparisons have to be based on indifference maps, as we have argued, then the Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives must be violated. The information which enables us to assert that individual A prefers x to y more strongly than B prefers y to x must be based on comparisons by A and B of x and y not only to each other but also to other alternatives. Kenneth J. Arrow, ‘Social Choice and Individual Values, p. 112. In a framework of preferences over lotteries, we show that an axiom system consisting of weakened versions of Arrow’s axioms has a unique solution. ‘Relative Utilitarianism’ consists of first normalizing individual von Neumann-Morgenstern utilities between 0 and 1 and then summing them.