p.399

Centralization and Decentralization in Economic Organizations

Thomas Marschak

Abstract

The preference for decentralization in the classic debates about planned production in a socialist economy has appeared more recently in the context of an organization that maximizes, subject to constraints, a scalar-valued function of its decisions. This article seeks a basis for the preference. A class of schemes for organizational decision-making is defined, and decentralized (in the classic sense), centralized, and unrestricted subclasses are considered. Criteria for ranking the schemes are obtained and applied in a simple illustrative organization. It is found that a general preference for one of the subclasses cannot be defended without further restricting the model substantially.